Dark Mode
Overview of the New USCIS Policy on Good Moral Character for Naturalization
In a significant policy shift introduced in 2025, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) now evaluates naturalization applicants under a new, more rigorous “holistic” standard for establishing good moral character (GMC). This change, part of a broader federal push for accountability and integrity in the naturalization process, places heightened emphasis not only on the absence of disqualifying conduct, but also on the presence of affirmative contributions to U.S. society.
The update redefines what it means to demonstrate good moral character, requiring more than just a clean record. For immigrants pursuing U.S. citizenship, this change underscores the critical need for preparation, documentation, and, in some cases, legal advocacy.
What Does a Holistic Good Moral Character Evaluation Mean?
Under the revised guidance, USCIS will now assess good moral character by taking into account an applicant’s entire life in the United States. This includes, but is not limited to:
-
Community involvement, including volunteerism, religious service, and civic engagement
-
Family caregiving responsibilities, especially in multi-generational or single-parent households
-
Educational attainment and efforts toward self-improvement
-
Stable and lawful employment history, demonstrating reliability and social integration
-
Length of lawful residence in the United States
-
Full compliance with federal and state tax laws
-
Fulfillment of child support obligations
Crucially, the presence of unpaid taxes or delinquent child support payments may result in an automatic denial of naturalization. These elements are now non-negotiable thresholds for approval.
Neighborhood Investigations: A New Frontier in USCIS Scrutiny
Perhaps the most striking feature of this new framework is the authorization of neighborhood investigations when questions arise regarding an applicant’s moral character. If USCIS officers harbor concerns about your behavior, character, or reputation, they are now permitted to:
-
Visit your neighbors and landlords to inquire about your conduct
-
Speak with co-workers and supervisors at your place of employment
-
Independently verify aspects of your personal life, social behavior, and reputation
While rare, these investigations are likely to be triggered in cases with red flags such as prior arrests, inconsistent documentation, complaints from others, or evidence of non-compliance with legal obligations.
How to Protect Your Naturalization Application
To mitigate the risk of delays, denials, or intrusive scrutiny, proactive applicants are now advised to assemble and submit character reference letters prior to their interview. These letters can come from:
-
Employers
-
Religious or community leaders
-
Teachers or school administrators
-
Neighbors or landlords
-
Family members not petitioning for you
These letters should outline your contributions, reliability, and community engagement. In our experience at Spar & Bernstein, clients who prepare these documents in advance and demonstrate full transparency with their USCIS officer have a substantially higher likelihood of approval.
Why Legal Representation Matters More Than Ever
At Spar & Bernstein, we’ve seen firsthand how nuanced and subjective these new good moral character determinations can be. A well-documented application can still be denied if it fails to tell a compelling story of who you are and the life you’ve built in the United States.
Our attorneys work closely with each client to build a customized portfolio that addresses every element of the holistic review—anticipating potential red flags and resolving them before USCIS has a chance to raise concerns. From preparing legal explanations of past tax or support issues to crafting persuasive documentation of your contributions, our team is here to support you at every step.
Your Path to Citizenship is Still Within Reach
Although this policy shift raises the bar, it also offers applicants an opportunity to showcase their full humanity and positive impact on society. If you’re prepared, supported, and legally guided, naturalization remains not only possible, but well within reach.
If you’re unsure how these changes might affect you—or if you have questions about whether your personal or financial history will raise concerns—contact Spar & Bernstein today. We’re ready to help you chart a confident and compliant path to U.S. citizenship.
